The best puppy training supplies make it easier to reward good choices, build routines, and handle early potty training without buying gear you won’t use. My best overall pick is Pupford Soft & Chewy Chicken Training Treats for their puppy-friendly soft format and usefulness during frequent reward sessions. HoAoOo Clickers suit owners who want a clear marker for training, while Earth Rated XL Pee Pads offer a practical backup for indoor potty routines. The main tradeoffs are treat size and ingredients, training style, and whether you need supplies for indoor management or outdoor habits. Read on for the full breakdown of all 12 options and how to choose the right mix for your puppy.
Get pet supplies delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Soft, easy-to-portion treats are the most flexible rewards for short, frequent puppy sessions; Pupford Chicken and Beef serve that role better than larger, single-ingredient pieces.
- Doorbells and pee pads solve different potty-training problems: bells can help a puppy signal a need to go outside, while pads manage indoor accidents or planned indoor potty areas.
- The two doorbell options prioritize different setups: the two-piece Dog Door Bells offer a simple hanging approach, while Luckyiren‘s upgraded bell is aimed at owners seeking a more developed doorbell setup.
- Clicker training depends on timing, not the clicker itself. The HoAoOo two-pack gives a compact marker option, but owners still need to pair the sound with a reward and practice consistent timing.
- Specialty treats and comfort tools address narrower needs. Freeze-dried liver and lamb lung offer single-ingredient reward choices, while the Snuggle Puppy toy is for settling and comfort rather than teaching cues.
| puppy training supplie | Brand |
|---|---|
| 2 Pcs Dog Door Bells | — |
| Wellness Soft Puppy Bites Dog | — |
| Mountain Wild Training Treats | Mountain Wild |
| Pupford Soft & Chewy Training | Pupford |
| HoAoOo Dog Training Clickers w | HoAoOo |
| Snuggle Puppy Heartbeat Dog To | — |
| Blue Buffalo Baby BLUE Savory | Blue Buffalo |
| Luckyiren Upgraded Dog Doorbel | Luckyiren |
| BARK’N BIG Lamb Lung Dog Treat | BARK’N BIG |
| Maev Single-Ingredient Freeze- | Maev |
| Earth Rated XL Dog and Puppy P | — |
| Pupford Soft & Chewy Beef Trai | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
2 Pcs Dog Door Bells – Pink Puppy Training Bell for Potty and Door Knob
For a puppy learning to signal that it needs to go outside, these bells offer a simple alternative to relying on scratching or barking. The 33- to 35-inch adjustable length is designed to hang from a door handle where a small dog can reach it, and the clear stainless-steel jingle gives the household an audible cue. The two-bell set can be useful if you want a spare or need bells in more than one spot. Unlike the HoAoOo Dog Training Clickers, these bells communicate a need to go out rather than mark a behavior during a lesson. The tradeoff is that a puppy must learn to ring them, and a bell alone does not teach house training. Its 2.8-inch bells may also feel oversized for very tiny pets.
Pros:- Adjustable hanging length fits many door knobs and handles
- Stainless-steel bells make a clear audible signal
- Two-piece set allows a spare or use at another door
- Compact paw-print design is intended for small pets to nudge
Cons:- Puppies need consistent practice to connect ringing with going outside
- The 2.8-inch bells may be too large for very tiny breeds
- Only works as a door signal when placed within the puppy’s reach
Best for: Puppy owners teaching a consistent door signal who have a reachable door handle and time to pair ringing with outdoor trips
Not ideal for: Owners of very tiny puppies or households needing an immediate potty solution without a training period
- Quantity:2 pieces
- Material:Stainless steel
- Color:Pink
- Adjustable length:33–35 inches
- Bell diameter:2.8 inches (7.2 cm)
- Item weight:5.9 ounces
- Manufacturer:KEXIAVA
Our verdict“Choose these bells if you want to teach a puppy a clear door signal; skip them if your pet is too small to reach or nudge the bells.”
Wellness Soft Puppy Bites Dog Training Treats, Natural, Grain Free, Lamb and Salmon Recipe, 3 oz Bag
These soft lamb-and-salmon bites suit owners who want a puppy reward with added nutritional features, not just a small training morsel. The recipe includes DHA and added vitamins, plus blueberries and sweet potatoes, while avoiding meat by-products and artificial colors and flavors. That ingredient profile sets it apart from Pupford Soft & Chewy Chicken Training Treats, which emphasize low calories and a mess-free texture rather than DHA. The soft texture is practical for quick rewards during short training repetitions. The main compromise is the 3-ounce bag: frequent sessions or a larger puppy can use it up quickly. It also contains lamb and salmon, so it is a less flexible pick for puppies with sensitivities to either protein.
Pros:- Soft bite-sized texture suits quick training rewards
- Includes DHA and added vitamins
- Contains blueberries and sweet potatoes
- Made without meat by-products, artificial colors, or artificial flavors
Cons:- The 3-ounce bag may run out quickly during frequent training
- Lamb and salmon limit suitability for puppies with sensitivities to those proteins
Best for: Puppy owners who want soft, bite-sized rewards with DHA and named lamb-and-salmon flavors in the recipe
Not ideal for: High-volume trainers who need a larger supply, or puppies that cannot tolerate lamb or salmon
- Weight:3 ounces
- Flavor:Lamb and salmon
- Form:Soft bites
- Diet feature:Grain-free
- Added nutrient:DHA
- Other listed ingredients:Blueberries and sweet potatoes
- Artificial colors and flavors:None listed
Our verdict“Pick Wellness Soft Puppy Bites if DHA and a soft lamb-and-salmon reward matter more to you than bag size or a low-calorie claim.”
Mountain Wild Training Treats for Dogs – Wild Elk & Venison – 4 oz, 2 Bags
When ordinary rewards fail to hold a puppy’s attention around distractions, Mountain Wild offers a more distinctive protein choice: wild-sourced elk and venison in small training nibs. Its grain-free recipe is described as free of artificial preservatives and fillers, and the approximately 300 nibs per bag give trainers plenty of small reward opportunities without handing over large pieces. Compared with Wellness Soft Puppy Bites, this pick focuses on wild-game protein and conservation support rather than DHA and added vitamins. The tradeoff is a narrow 4-ounce bag size, which may mean replenishing often during intensive training. The product is also described as a raw diet, so owners should check whether that approach suits their feeding preferences.
Pros:- Wild-sourced elk and venison provide a distinctive protein reward
- Small nib size works for repeated training cues and dogs of different sizes
- Grain-free and described as free of artificial preservatives and fillers
- Purchase supports wildlife conservation and anti-poaching efforts
Cons:- The 4-ounce bag size may require frequent replenishment for heavy training
- The listed raw diet may not suit every owner’s feeding preferences
Best for: Handlers seeking small, high-value wild-game rewards for training across puppy and adult life stages
Not ideal for: Owners who prefer conventional cooked treats, need large-volume supplies, or avoid wild-game proteins
- Brand:Mountain Wild
- Flavor:Venison; description also lists elk
- Item form:Nib
- Item weight:4 ounces
- Treat count:Approximately 300 nibs per bag
- Life stages:All life stages
- Diet type:Raw
- Diet feature:Grain-free
Our verdict“Choose Mountain Wild for small wild-game rewards when novelty and protein matter more than a larger bag or a conventional treat format.”
Pupford Soft & Chewy Training Treats for Dogs & Puppies (Chicken, 5 oz)
Pupford’s clearest training advantage is portion control: each bite contains less than 2 calories, making repeated rewards easier to fit into a session than larger or richer pieces. The chicken-and-sweet-potato recipe is presented as simple, and the soft, crumb-free texture suits puppies as well as older dogs with sensitive teeth. Compared with Wellness Soft Puppy Bites, which add DHA and a broader set of listed ingredients, Pupford puts more emphasis on low-calorie, clean handling. Compared with Mountain Wild’s wild-game nibs, it offers a familiar chicken flavor. Its limits are a single listed flavor and a 5-ounce bag that may not last long for heavy users; the description also gives no broader ingredient detail beyond chicken and sweet potato.
Pros:- Less than 2 calories per treat supports frequent rewarding
- Soft texture is gentle on puppy and senior teeth
- Bite-sized pieces suit repetition-based training
- Described as crumb-free and made in the USA
Cons:- Only chicken is listed as a flavor option for this variant
- The 5-ounce bag may run out quickly during heavy training
- Listed ingredients are limited to chicken and sweet potato, with little detail about the full recipe
Best for: Owners running frequent reward-based sessions who want small, soft chicken treats with a stated calorie limit
Not ideal for: Trainers seeking several flavor options, a large supply, or the wild-game protein choice offered by Mountain Wild
- Brand:Pupford
- Flavor:Chicken
- Weight:5 ounces
- Calories:Less than 2 kcal per treat
- Ingredients listed:Chicken and sweet potato
- Form:Bite-sized, soft and chewy
- Life stage:All life stages
- Origin:Made in the USA
Our verdict“Pick Pupford Chicken when you want low-calorie, tidy rewards for frequent practice and do not need multiple flavors or a larger bag.”
HoAoOo Dog Training Clickers with Wrist Straps and Keyrings, 2-Pack
Clicker training depends on precise timing: a distinct sound marks the behavior you want, then a reward follows. This two-pack gives you two differently colored clickers, so you can keep one in another room or share a training setup, while the stretchable wrist straps help keep a clicker close at hand. Unlike the 2 Pcs Dog Door Bells, which let a puppy signal for outdoor access, these clickers are for marking actions such as sitting or coming when called. They also do not replace a food reward; pairing the sound with treats such as Pupford Soft & Chewy Chicken Training Treats is part of the training process. The simple design is versatile across several animal types, but this set does not include a treat pouch or other reward supplies.
Pros:- Two clickers provide a spare or support separate training locations
- Black and blue colors make the devices easy to tell apart
- Stretchable wrist straps help keep a clicker within reach
- Suitable for training dogs, cats, birds, and horses
Cons:- Does not include treats or another reward to reinforce the marked behavior
- Clicker sound alone does not teach a cue without consistent timing and follow-up rewards
Best for: New clicker trainers who want a spare device or a second clicker for training in more than one location
Not ideal for: Owners seeking an all-in-one training kit or a potty signal rather than a behavior marker
- Brand:HoAoOo
- Quantity:2 clickers
- Colors:Black and blue
- Wrist strap length:16 cm (6.3 inches), stretches to 25 cm (9.84 inches)
- Item weight:41 g (1.45 ounces)
- Model:ch-clicker01
- Suitable animals:Dogs, cats, birds, and horses
Our verdict“Choose this set if you are ready to pair a clear click with rewards; skip it if you need a complete training kit or a doorbell-style potty cue.”
Snuggle Puppy Heartbeat Dog Toy with Heat Pack – Brown & White Beagle
For a puppy whose training hurdle is settling alone, the Snuggle Puppy fills a different role from the treats and doorbells in this roundup: it offers comfort rather than a direct cue or reward. Its heartbeat device and included heat pack are designed to mimic a warm companion, which may help make crate time or a new sleeping spot feel less isolating. Compared with the Luckyiren Dog Doorbells, which teach a puppy to signal for outdoor access, this is aimed at easing stress around rest and separation. The washable plush helps with upkeep, but the heartbeat needs batteries and the heat pack is single-use. I’d choose it for a puppy needing settling support, not as a substitute for gradual crate training or active instruction.
Pros:- Heartbeat device offers a comforting pulse for crate or sleep routines.
- Included heat pack adds warmth when used as directed.
- Washable plush exterior can be cleaned after removing internal components.
- Designed for anxiety relief, crate training, travel, and teething.
Cons:- Heartbeat function requires batteries.
- Included heat pack is disposable and must be replaced.
- Comfort support does not teach cues or replace gradual crate training.
Best for: New puppy owners working on quiet crate settling, sleep routines, or short periods of separation.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking a direct training cue or a maintenance-free comfort toy, since the heartbeat needs batteries and heat packs need replacement.
- Toy type:Plush
- Material:Polyester
- Color:Brown & White
- Dimensions:12 x 6.5 x 5 inches
- Item weight:16 ounces
- Features:Heartbeat device and disposable heat pack
- Water resistance:Water resistant
- Recommended uses:Anxiety relief, teething, crate training, indoor/outdoor
Our verdict“Choose the Snuggle Puppy if your priority is helping a new puppy settle, rather than rewarding commands or teaching a potty signal.”
Blue Buffalo Baby BLUE Savory Chicken Puppy Training Treats, 4 oz
Baby BLUE Savory Chicken treats suit frequent, ordinary training sessions where a puppy needs a soft, easy-to-eat reward. Chicken is the first ingredient, and the tender bite-sized texture makes them more practical for repeated cues than a treat that needs breaking apart. Compared with BARK’N BIG Lamb Lung, these offer a soft morsel rather than a light, crunchy single-ingredient treat, while lamb lung gives buyers a different protein option. The recipe includes DHA and avoids corn, wheat, soy, poultry by-product meals, artificial colors, and artificial preservatives. The main compromise is the 4-ounce bag: regular practice can use it up quickly, especially in a busy household. I’d pick this for routine puppy lessons, not for anyone needing a larger supply or a single-ingredient recipe.
Pros:- Chicken is the first ingredient.
- Soft, bite-sized morsels are convenient for repeated training rewards.
- Includes DHA.
- Free of corn, wheat, soy, poultry by-product meals, artificial colors, and artificial preservatives.
Cons:- The 4-ounce bag may run out quickly during frequent practice.
- Chicken flavor offers less protein variety than lamb lung options.
- Not a single-ingredient formula.
Best for: Puppy owners who want soft, bite-sized chicken rewards for short, frequent sessions across different breed sizes.
Not ideal for: High-volume trainers who want a larger bag, or buyers seeking a single-ingredient treat with a novel protein.
- Brand:Blue Buffalo
- Flavor:Chicken
- Life stage:Puppy
- Form:Semi-moist, soft bite-sized morsels
- Weight:4 ounces
- First ingredient:Chicken
- Special ingredient:DHA
- Dietary features:Corn-free, wheat-free, soy-free; no artificial colors or preservatives
Our verdict“Choose Baby BLUE for soft, everyday puppy rewards if a small chicken-treat bag fits your training routine.”
Luckyiren Upgraded Dog Doorbells for Potty Training and Outdoor Access
The Luckyiren Dog Doorbells are the clearest choice here for teaching a puppy to communicate a need to go outside. The adjustable nylon strap has three snap points, so owners can set the bells at a reachable height instead of relying on a fixed placement. Their crisp jingle creates an audible signal; that makes them a different kind of training aid from Baby BLUE Chicken treats, which reward a behavior but do not provide a way to request a bathroom break. The bells are built for repeated use, with rust-resistant plating and a two-year manufacturer warranty listed. The tradeoff is that the bell only helps if the puppy learns to use it and the household responds consistently. I’d skip it if you want a tool that works without active teaching.
Pros:- Three snap points let owners adjust strap length for different dogs and door heights.
- Clear jingle provides an audible potty or outdoor-access signal.
- Nylon strap and connection points are designed for repeated use.
- Rust-resistant bell plating and a listed two-year manufacturer warranty.
Cons:- Requires consistent training and follow-through to teach the signal.
- A puppy may ring for attention or outdoor access rather than only for a bathroom break.
- Not useful for dogs that do not respond to bell training.
Best for: Owners ready to pair doorbell practice with consistent bathroom trips and a prompt response to each ring.
Not ideal for: Households unable to supervise or reinforce bell use, or puppies that do not respond to sound-based signaling.
- Brand:Luckyiren
- Materials:Nylon strap, iron bell, stainless steel ball
- Color:Black
- Dimensions:32 x 2.8 x 2.8 inches
- Item weight:3.84 ounces
- Adjustability:Three snap points
- Warranty:Two-year manufacturer warranty
- Target audience:Dogs, puppies, and cats
Our verdict“Choose Luckyiren if you want to teach a puppy an audible way to request outdoor access and can reinforce it consistently.”
BARK’N BIG Lamb Lung Dog Treats – Single Ingredient Dehydrated Training Treats, 5 oz
BARK’N BIG Lamb Lung stands out for buyers who want a simple ingredient list and a protein other than chicken or beef. The dehydrated pieces are light and can be snapped into smaller rewards, making them adaptable for repeated practice; crumbling them over kibble also gives the bag another use beyond training. Compared with Maev Beef Liver, this is the lamb-based option, while Maev is freeze-dried beef liver with USDA-certified, human-grade sourcing. The single-ingredient lamb lung may suit households avoiding common proteins, but it is not as tidy as a uniform soft morsel: its crumbly texture can leave bits behind. Its five-ounce weight also belies how quickly a light treat can be used during heavy training. I’d favor it for ingredient-conscious owners who value flexibility over neat handling.
Pros:- Lamb lung is the single ingredient, with no grains, fillers, or preservatives listed.
- Novel protein offers an alternative to common chicken and beef treats.
- Light pieces can be snapped into smaller rewards or crumbled over kibble.
- Listed as low fat and high protein, with sourcing and production in the USA.
Cons:- Crumbly texture can leave a mess in pockets or treat pouches.
- Lightweight pieces may be used up quickly during frequent training.
- Crunchy texture may be less convenient than soft morsels for rapid reward delivery.
Best for: Owners seeking a single-ingredient, grain-free lamb reward for dogs avoiding chicken or beef, including puppies in training.
Not ideal for: Trainers who need clean, uniform pieces for rapid sessions or want a dense treat that lasts through heavy daily use.
- Brand:BARK’N BIG
- Weight:5 ounces
- Ingredient:Lamb lung
- Processing:Dehydrated
- Dietary features:Limited ingredient, grain-free
- Life stage:All life stages
- Breed size:All breed sizes
- Origin:Made and sourced in the USA
Our verdict“Choose BARK’N BIG if a single-protein lamb treat matters more than tidy handling or long-lasting supply.”
Maev Single-Ingredient Freeze-Dried Raw Beef Liver Dog Treats
Maev Freeze-Dried Beef Liver is the pick for training moments when a more distinctive reward may help hold a puppy’s attention. Its single-ingredient beef liver formula keeps the ingredient list straightforward, and freeze-drying makes it a different format from the crunchy, dehydrated BARK’N BIG Lamb Lung. The beef option may appeal to dogs that enjoy organ-meat treats, while lamb lung gives owners an alternative protein for dogs avoiding beef. Maev also lists USDA-certified, human-grade sourcing from the USA. The tradeoffs are a 4.4-ounce package and only one flavor, so it is less flexible for households rotating proteins or training heavily every day. I’d reserve it for selective rewards or a puppy that needs extra motivation, rather than treating it as the only everyday snack.
Pros:- Made with beef liver as the sole ingredient, with no fillers, grains, or artificial additives listed.
- Freeze-dried format offers a distinct alternative to dehydrated lamb lung.
- USDA-certified, human-grade sourcing is listed.
- Designed as a high-value reward for training and picky eaters.
Cons:- Beef liver is the only flavor and protein option.
- The 4.4-ounce package may be limiting for frequent training.
- Not suitable for dogs that need to avoid beef.
Best for: Owners who want a single-ingredient beef liver reward for selective puppies or especially engaging training sessions.
Not ideal for: Dogs avoiding beef, households wanting protein variety, or trainers who need a larger everyday supply.
- Brand:Maev
- Weight:4.4 ounces
- Ingredient:Beef liver
- Processing method:Freeze-dried
- Origin:USA
- Certification:USDA-certified, human-grade
Our verdict“Choose Maev for a beef-liver reward aimed at selective puppies, but pick lamb lung instead if you need a non-beef protein.”
Earth Rated XL Dog and Puppy Pee Pads, 40 Count
For puppy households that need a designated indoor potty spot, these extra-large unscented pads offer more coverage than a small training target. AbsorbShield+ layers are stated to absorb liquid faster and in greater volume, while the adhesive tabs help limit sliding on hard floors—a practical difference when a puppy is still learning to aim. A built-in attractant may encourage use, though individual dogs can respond differently, and the discreet green surface makes messes less prominent. Unlike the Pupford Soft & Chewy Beef Training Treats, this is a cleanup and potty-location aid rather than a reward for a successful cue. The tradeoff is that pad training depends on consistent placement, and even an XL pad can miss liquid when a puppy does not aim near the center.
Pros:- Extra-large size provides a broader target for young puppies.
- Adhesive tabs help hold the pad in place on hard floors.
- Unscented construction avoids added fragrance.
- Layered design and built-in attractant support containment and potty practice.
Cons:- The attractant may not influence every dog.
- Containment works best when the puppy aims near the center.
Best for: Puppy owners in apartments or homes who need a larger indoor potty area on hard flooring.
Not ideal for: Owners focused on outdoor-only potty training, or puppies that routinely miss the pad’s central area.
- Product type:Dog and puppy pee pads
- Size:Extra large
- Count:40
- Scent:Unscented
- Absorbency:AbsorbShield+ technology; stated to absorb 2x faster and 2x more
- Leak prevention:Layered leak-prevention design
- Placement and training features:Adhesive tabs and built-in training attractant
- Surface:Discreet green
Our verdict“Choose these pads if your puppy needs a roomy, secured indoor potty target, but look elsewhere if you are training exclusively outdoors.”
Pupford Soft & Chewy Beef Training Treats for Dogs and Puppies, 5 oz
When a puppy needs many small rewards during a session, these soft, one-bite beef treats keep each payoff under 2 calories. Their easy-to-chew texture can also suit senior dogs with sensitive teeth, making them more adaptable across ages than treats that require extra chewing. Compared with Wellness Soft Puppy Bites, this option’s defining advantage is its stated low calorie count per treat, while its specified flavor is limited to beef. The simple-ingredient recipe has no artificial additives or fillers, and the treats are made in the USA. That combination fits repeat practice better than a larger, occasional reward, but the 5 oz bag may not stretch far for frequent sessions, and buyers seeking flavor variety will need another option.
Pros:- Each treat contains less than 2 calories, supporting frequent rewards.
- Small, one-bite pieces are suited to repeated training cues.
- Soft texture may work well for puppies and dogs with sensitive teeth.
- Made in the USA with simple ingredients and no fillers or artificial additives.
Cons:- Only beef flavor is specified.
- The 5 oz package may be limiting for households doing frequent or extended training.
Best for: Puppy guardians who reward repeatedly during short training sessions and want small, soft treats with a stated calorie count.
Not ideal for: Dogs that reject beef or owners who want multiple specified flavors in one training treat option.
- Flavor:Beef
- Net weight:5 oz
- Calories per treat:Less than 2 kcal
- Texture:Soft and chewy
- Treat size:One-bite
- Made in:USA
- Ingredients:Simple ingredients; no artificial additives or fillers
Our verdict“Pick these for frequent, low-calorie beef rewards in a soft bite, but skip them if your dog needs flavor variety.”
How We Picked
I ranked these supplies by how directly they support common puppy-training tasks: rewarding behavior, marking a correct response, building a potty routine, and helping a puppy settle. I gave more weight to items with a clear everyday training role, easy handling during repeated sessions, and a format that can fit into a practical routine. Treats were compared by their stated texture and ingredient approach, while potty tools and the clicker were judged by the specific problem they address.
The ranking also reflects versatility and tradeoffs. Soft training treats and a simple clicker can serve many early lessons, which puts them ahead of more specialized comfort or ingredient-focused products for most new owners. Pads, doorbells, and the heartbeat toy can be useful in specific homes, but they are not interchangeable and won’t suit every training plan. I considered the full set as a practical toolkit rather than assuming every puppy needs all 12 items.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Puppy Training Supplies
A useful puppy-training kit is not a pile of products; it is a small set of tools matched to your training plan, home, and puppy. I would start by choosing how you will reward behavior and manage potty routines, then add specialty supplies only where a clear need exists.
Choose rewards your puppy can eat repeatedly
Training often means several small rewards in a short period, so a treat that is easy to break or portion can be more practical than a large piece. Check the ingredient list for foods your puppy already tolerates, especially if you are introducing treats alongside a new diet. A single-ingredient treat may appeal to owners who want a simpler ingredient profile, but its texture or size may make it less convenient for rapid-fire practice. Avoid offering several new treat types at once, since that makes it harder to identify what caused an upset stomach or sensitivity. Keep training pieces small enough that the reward does not end the session or displace too much of a puppy’s regular food.
Match potty tools to the routine you want to build
Doorbells work as a communication cue when you want a puppy to signal before going outside; they do not teach house training on their own. Pee pads can help manage indoor needs, but placing them in different rooms or moving them repeatedly may make the intended potty spot less clear. Decide whether pads are a temporary support, a permanent indoor option, or a backup for times when outdoor access is limited. For an outdoor routine, take the puppy out on a predictable schedule and pair the bell with those trips rather than waiting for the puppy to figure out the connection. Choose one main approach and keep its location and cues consistent.
Use a clicker only if its sound fits your training style
A clicker can mark the exact moment a puppy performs a behavior, which helps separate the cue from the reward that follows. It is not a reward by itself: the puppy needs to learn that the sound predicts something pleasant. Some owners prefer a verbal marker such as “yes,” which is easier to carry everywhere and does not require a separate tool. If you choose a clicker, practice clicking and immediately rewarding before using it to teach new skills. A wrist strap or spare clicker can help with handling, but consistent timing matters more than accessories.
Plan for the puppy’s age, chewing, and attention span
Young puppies tire quickly, and short sessions with clear rewards usually fit their attention better than long drills. A comfort toy may support settling in a new home, but it serves a different purpose from a treat or training marker and should not be counted as a lesson tool. Check any toy or supply for suitability to your puppy’s size and chewing habits, and supervise items that could be damaged. Keep sessions simple: teach one small behavior at a time, then stop while the puppy can still engage. This makes it easier to tell whether a product is helping or simply adding stimulation.
Pay for a specific advantage, not a bigger kit
More supplies do not automatically make training faster. A premium or specialty treat makes sense when its ingredients, format, or your puppy’s preferences solve a real problem, while a basic soft treat may cover routine practice just as well. A second doorbell or clicker is useful when you need another location or a spare, but redundant tools can add clutter without changing the training plan. Before buying, identify the task you want the product to support and how often you expect to use it. If you cannot name that task, start with a small selection and add equipment after a need becomes clear.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I use pee pads and doorbells at the same time?
You can use both, but decide what each one is meant to do. A doorbell can signal an outdoor trip, while a pad provides an indoor potty spot; without a consistent plan, a puppy may receive mixed cues about where to go. If your goal is outdoor toileting, make outdoor trips the main routine and use pads only as a clearly defined backup. If indoor toileting is part of your longer-term plan, place pads in a consistent area and teach that location. Keep supervision and scheduled breaks in place whichever setup you choose.
Are soft treats better than single-ingredient treats for puppy training?
Neither type is automatically better for every puppy. Soft treats are often easier to portion and deliver quickly during repeated cue practice, while single-ingredient options may suit owners who prefer a simpler ingredient list. Your puppy’s ability to chew the treat comfortably, digestive tolerance, and willingness to work for it matter more than the label category. Introduce new treats gradually and keep portions small. If your puppy has dietary restrictions or a health concern, ask your veterinarian which ingredients fit their needs.
Does a clicker work if I already use verbal praise?
Yes, a clicker can be used alongside verbal praise, but it helps to give each signal a consistent role. The click marks the behavior at a precise moment, and a treat or other reward follows; praise can add encouragement without replacing that sequence. If you can mark behavior reliably with a short word, you may not need a clicker at all. The better choice is the marker you can use accurately in the situations where you train. Practice the timing before adding the marker to a new skill.
How many types of training treats should I keep on hand?
Most new owners can start with one everyday training treat and add another only for a clear reason, such as a different ingredient preference or a more exciting reward for a distracting setting. Using too many new foods at once can make it hard to track digestive reactions and can complicate portion control. If you rotate treats, keep pieces small and account for them alongside your puppy’s regular meals. Store treats according to the package directions so their texture remains suitable for training. Ask your veterinarian about treat limits if your puppy has a medical or dietary concern.
Do I need a heartbeat toy to help a new puppy settle?
No, a heartbeat toy is an optional comfort aid, not a required training supply. Some puppies may benefit from a familiar-feeling settling aid, while others may prefer a quiet sleeping area and a predictable bedtime routine. Introduce any toy under supervision and check it regularly for damage, especially if your puppy chews fabric or seams. Keep the sleeping space safe and follow guidance from your veterinarian or breeder about settling a young puppy. Choose the toy only if comfort during rest is a need you want to address.
Conclusion
For an all-purpose starting point, I recommend Pupford Soft & Chewy Chicken Training Treats as the best overall fit for frequent reward-based practice; the Beef version is a sensible alternative if you prefer that recipe. For best value, the HoAoOo two-pack clickers make sense when you want a simple marker tool and a spare. For a premium, ingredient-focused reward, consider Maev Freeze-Dried Beef Liver, while Earth Rated XL Pee Pads are the more targeted choice for indoor potty management. New owners can start with soft treats and one clear potty plan, then add Luckyiren bells for outdoor signaling or the Snuggle Puppy for settling support only if those needs arise. The best kit is the smallest set that fits your puppy’s routine and helps you reward the behaviors you want to repeat.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
