Choosing the best grain free dog and cat food requires balancing ingredient quality with your pet’s specific dietary needs. My top overall pick is Loyal Saints Freeze-Dried Raw Turkey and Salmon Dog Food because it offers minimal processing and high bioavailability, ideal for pets with severe sensitivities. For those seeking a convenient dry option, The Honest Kitchen Grain-Free Turkey & Superfoods Whole Food Clusters stands out for its human-grade ingredients and easy rehydration. However, buyers must weigh the higher cost of premium raw or freeze-dried options against the convenience of kibble. The main tradeoff in this category is often between ingredient purity and shelf stability. Continue reading to see how these nine options compare on nutrition, palatability, and value.
Get pet supplies delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Freeze-dried options like Loyal Saints offer the highest nutrient retention but require more preparation time than standard kibble.
- Wet food options such as Evanger’s provide superior hydration for both dogs and cats, which is critical for urinary health in felines.
- Limited-ingredient formulas like Natural Balance are specifically designed for pets with known allergies, reducing the risk of adverse reactions.
- Multi-species compatibility is rare; most products are formulated specifically for either dogs or cats due to differing taurine and protein needs.
- Premium grain-free kibble often uses legumes or potatoes as carbohydrate sources, which some veterinary studies suggest monitoring for cardiac health.
| grain free dog and cat food | Brand | Life stage | Flavor | Form |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Loyal Saints Freeze-Dried Raw | Loyal Saints | All life stages | Turkey and salmon | Freeze-dried |
| The Honest Kitchen Grain-Free | The Honest Kitchen | All life stages | Turkey | Pellet clusters |
| Evanger’s Grain-Free Chicken W | Evanger’s | All life stages | Chicken | Chunks |
| Natural Balance Limited Ingred | Natural Balance | Adult | Salmon & Green Pea | Pellet |
| Nature’s Logic Grain-Free Beef | Nature’s Logic | All life stages | Beef | Dry |
| Grandma Mae’s Country Naturals | Grandma Mae’s Country Naturals | Adult (Senior/Weight Control) | — | — |
| Jinx Grain-Free Dry Dog Food w | Jinx | All Life Stages | — | — |
| I AND LOVE AND YOU Naked Essen | I AND LOVE AND YOU | Adult | — | — |
| Blue Buffalo Wilderness Chicke | Blue Buffalo | Adult | — | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Loyal Saints Freeze-Dried Raw Turkey and Salmon Dog Food, 14 oz
This option stands out for owners seeking high-bioavailability raw nutrition without the hassle of frozen storage. Unlike the Nature’s Logic Grain-Free Beef Meal Feast, which relies on processed meat meals, Loyal Saints uses cage-free turkey and salmon that retains natural enzymes and nutrients through freeze-drying. The inclusion of USDA-certified organic fruits and vegetables offers a cleaner ingredient profile than many competitors. However, the 14 oz package size makes it expensive for daily feeding of large dogs, and the rehydration requirement adds prep time. It is best viewed as a premium topper or small-dog meal rather than a bulk staple.
Pros:- Uses cage-free turkey and salmon for high-quality protein
- No refrigeration required, unlike fresh raw diets
- Includes USDA-certified organic fruits and vegetables
- Versatile usage as a meal, topper, or training treat
Cons:- Small 14 oz bag makes it cost-prohibitive for large dogs
- Requires rehydration with warm water for complete meals
- Not suitable for growth stages of breeds over 60 lbs
Best for: Small dog owners prioritizing raw nutrition and willing to pay a premium for organic ingredients.
Not ideal for: Owners of large breeds over 60 lbs, as it does not support growth stages for that size range.
- Brand:Loyal Saints
- Flavor:Turkey and salmon
- Form:Freeze-dried
- Net weight:14 oz
- Life stage:All life stages
- Special ingredients:Turkey, turkey liver, turkey heart, salmon, fruits, vegetables, flaxseed, and chia seed
- Diet claims:Raw, grain-free, high-protein
Our verdict“Choose this if you want raw benefits with dry convenience and have a small dog.”
The Honest Kitchen Grain-Free Turkey & Superfoods Whole Food Clusters Dry Dog Food, 5 lb
This model is better suited to owners who want human-grade ingredients in a dry format. Compared to Loyal Saints, it offers a larger 5 lb bag, making it more practical for daily feeding, though it lacks the raw enzyme profile. The clusters are minimally processed, preserving the integrity of the turkey and superfoods like pumpkin and kale. It includes probiotics and taurine to support digestion and heart health, a feature less prominent in basic grain-free kibbles. The tradeoff is the smaller package size, which may require frequent reordering for multi-dog households.
Pros:- Made with human-grade whole food ingredients
- Includes probiotics, fiber, and antioxidants
- Designed to support skin, coat, and digestion
Cons:- Small 5 lb bag size may require frequent reordering
- Feeding amounts vary significantly by dog size and activity
- Lacks detailed nutrient analysis compared to raw options
Best for: Owners who prioritize human-grade, minimally processed ingredients and have small to medium dogs.
Not ideal for: Owners looking for bulk value, as the 5 lb bag runs out quickly for larger dogs.
- Brand:The Honest Kitchen
- Flavor:Turkey
- Weight:5 lb
- Life Stage:All life stages
- Form:Pellet clusters
- Primary Ingredient:Cage-free turkey
- Dietary Features:Grain-free, gluten-free, no artificial flavors
- Key Ingredients:Pumpkin, apples, carrots, broccoli, kale, chia seeds, flaxseed, coconut oil, fish oil, probiotics, taurine
Our verdict“This is ideal if you want human-grade quality in a convenient dry format for smaller dogs.”
Evanger’s Grain-Free Chicken Wet Food for Dogs and Cats, 6 oz Cans, 24 Count
This pick makes the most sense for households with both dogs and cats, offering a single product for all. Unlike the Natural Balance Limited Ingredient Adult Dry Cat Food, which is species-specific and dry, Evanger’s provides high moisture content via chunks in broth. The single-protein chicken recipe is excellent for pets with multiple food sensitivities, though it is unsuitable for those allergic to chicken. As a limited-ingredient diet, it lacks the comprehensive nutrient balance of complete meals, so it is best used as a topper or supplement rather than the sole diet.
Pros:- Single-protein chicken recipe for sensitivity management
- Suitable for both dogs and cats
- High moisture content from cooking in broth
Cons:- Not a complete balanced diet for daily feeding
- Unsuitable for pets with chicken allergies
- Limited ingredient profile may lack specific nutrients
Best for: Multi-pet homes with dogs and cats needing a simple, limited-ingredient wet topper.
Not ideal for: Pets with chicken allergies or owners seeking a complete, balanced daily meal.
- Brand:Evanger’s
- Flavor:Chicken
- Package Size:24 cans, 6 oz each
- Main Ingredient:Chicken
- Target Species:Dogs and cats
- Life Stage:All life stages
- Diet Type:Limited ingredient, grain-free
- Form:Chunks
Our verdict“Buy this as a versatile topper for mixed dog and cat households with dietary sensitivities.”
Natural Balance Limited Ingredient Adult Dry Cat Food, Salmon & Green Pea, 10 lb
While Evanger’s serves both species, this formula is strictly for adult cats, providing targeted nutrition they need. The salmon and green pea combination offers a single animal protein source, making it a reliable choice for cats with common food allergies. It is free of corn, soy, and wheat, supporting digestion and coat health. However, unlike the Jinx Grain-Free Dry Dog Food which includes sweet potatoes, this relies on peas, which some cats may not tolerate. It is a specialized option, not a universal solution for all pets.
Pros:- Salmon provides a single animal protein source
- Free of corn, soy, and wheat
- Designed to support digestion, skin, and coat
Cons:- Intended only for adult cats
- May not suit cats with salmon or green pea sensitivities
- Dry format offers less hydration than wet foods
Best for: Adult cats with food sensitivities who need a grain-free, single-protein dry food.
Not ideal for: Kittens or senior cats with specific needs, as this is formulated for adults only.
- Brand:Natural Balance
- Flavor:Salmon & Green Pea
- Life Stage:Adult
- Form:Pellet
- Weight:10 lb
- Target Species:Cat
- Diet Type:Limited Ingredient
- Allergen Information:Corn-free, grain-free, soy-free, wheat-free
Our verdict“Select this if you have an adult cat with allergies and prefer a dry kibble format.”
Nature’s Logic Grain-Free Beef Meal Feast Dry Dog Food, 25 lb
This option stands out for large breed owners seeking a cost-effective grain-free solution. Compared to the Loyal Saints Freeze-Dried Raw, the 25 lb bag offers significantly better value per feeding, though it uses beef meal rather than fresh meat. It includes probiotics, prebiotics, and digestive enzymes to support gut health, which is beneficial for dogs with sensitive stomachs. However, the presence of millet despite the grain-free label may confuse owners strictly avoiding all grains. It is a practical, no-nonsense choice for feeding many dogs.
Pros:- Beef meal is the main ingredient
- Large 25 lb bag offers good value for large dogs
- Includes probiotics, prebiotics, and digestive enzymes
Cons:- Contains millet, which is technically a grain
- Uses meat meal rather than fresh meat
- Protein content description may vary from label details
Best for: Owners of large dogs or multiple pets who need a budget-friendly, grain-free dry food.
Not ideal for: Owners who strictly avoid all grains, including millet, or prefer fresh meat over meals.
- Brand:Nature’s Logic
- Flavor:Beef
- Weight:25 lb
- Form:Dry
- Life Stage:All life stages
- Protein:33% crude protein; 97% of protein from meat sources
- Crude Fat:15%
- Calories:406 kcal per cup
Our verdict“This is the go-to choice for feeding large dogs or multiple pets on a grain-free budget.”
Grandma Mae’s Country Naturals Grain-Free Pork Dry Dog Food
This formula stands out for its low-temperature slow-cooking process, which aims to preserve nutrient integrity better than high-heat extrusion methods often used in standard kibble. Compared to the Jinx Salmon Dog Food, which focuses on high energy for active dogs, Grandma Mae’s prioritizes weight control, making it a safer bet for older pets with slowing metabolisms. The inclusion of dried kelp and flaxseed supports joint health and coat condition without the calorie density of heavier formulas. However, the lack of a publicly detailed full ingredient analysis makes it harder to verify specific nutrient ratios compared to more transparent brands. It is a solid choice for owners who trust the brand’s philosophy but may require careful monitoring of caloric intake to prevent underfeeding.
Pros:- Slow-cooked at low temperatures to retain nutrients
- Free of common allergens like corn, soy, and wheat
- Specifically formulated for weight control and senior needs
- Made in the USA without artificial preservatives
Cons:- Full ingredient list and nutritional analysis are not readily available
- Limited flavor options compared to broader brand lines
Best for: Owners of senior dogs or overweight pets needing a nutrient-dense but calorie-controlled diet.
Not ideal for: High-energy working dogs or puppies who require higher fat and protein levels for growth and activity.
- Brand:Grandma Mae’s Country Naturals
- Primary Protein:Pork
- Life Stage:Adult (Senior/Weight Control)
- Cooking Method:Low-temperature, slow-cooked
- Bag Size:23 lb
- Diet Type:Grain-free, limited ingredient
- Origin:USA
Our verdict“This food is best for owners prioritizing digestive ease and weight management for older dogs.”
Jinx Grain-Free Dry Dog Food with Salmon
Jinx distinguishes itself with Atlantic salmon as the first ingredient, providing a potent source of omega-3 fatty acids that directly support skin and coat health. Unlike the Grandma Mae’s Pork formula, which targets weight management, Jinx is designed for all life stages and breed sizes, offering broader versatility for multi-pet households. The addition of probiotics and fiber-rich sweet potatoes aids digestion, a feature less emphasized in simpler formulas. However, potential buyers must note a significant labeling inconsistency: the title claims grain-free status while the ingredient list includes brown rice. This contradiction suggests a need for caution if strict grain avoidance is a medical requirement. It remains a strong contender for owners prioritizing visible coat improvements over strict dietary exclusions.
Pros:- Atlantic salmon is the primary protein source
- Rich in omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids
- Contains added probiotics for digestive support
- Suitable for all breed sizes and life stages
Cons:- Conflicting information regarding grain-free status (lists brown rice)
- Small 4 lb bag size may require frequent reordering
- Contains tree nuts, a potential allergen for some dogs
Best for: Dog owners seeking noticeable improvements in coat shine and skin health across all life stages.
Not ideal for: Owners requiring strict grain-free certification due to the conflicting ingredient list including brown rice.
- Brand:Jinx
- Primary Protein:Atlantic Salmon
- Life Stage:All Life Stages
- Bag Size:4 lb
- Key Nutrients:Omega-3 & Omega-6, Probiotics
- Diet Features:Grain-free (label conflict), High Protein
- Allergen Info:Fish, Tree Nuts
Our verdict“Choose Jinx for its high-quality salmon protein and coat benefits, but verify ingredient tolerance due to labeling inconsistencies.”
I AND LOVE AND YOU Naked Essentials Grain-Free Dry Cat Food
This formula is engineered for felines with digestive sensitivities, featuring prebiotics and probiotics to stabilize gut flora. Compared to the Blue Buffalo Wilderness Chicken, which emphasizes immune support through antioxidants, I AND LOVE AND YOU focuses more heavily on gastrointestinal comfort. The 34% protein content provides adequate energy for adult cats, while the exclusion of corn, wheat, and soy reduces common inflammatory triggers. The dual protein source of chicken and duck offers variety, which can help prevent dietary boredom. However, cats with specific poultry allergies will need to avoid this, as both primary proteins are poultry-based. It is a balanced choice for owners who want a grain-free option that prioritizes gut health without compromising on protein quality.
Pros:- Includes prebiotics and probiotics for digestion
- 34% protein content supports muscle maintenance
- Free of corn, wheat, rice, soy, and oats
- Uses USA farm-raised chicken and duck
Cons:- Contains poultry, unsuitable for cats with chicken/duck sensitivities
- Small 3.4 lb bag size limits long-term convenience
Best for: Adult cats with mild digestive upsets or owners looking for a gut-health-focused grain-free diet.
Not ideal for: Cats with known chicken or duck allergies, or kittens requiring higher caloric density for growth.
- Brand:I AND LOVE AND YOU
- Primary Protein:Chicken & Duck
- Protein Content:34%
- Life Stage:Adult
- Bag Size:3.4 lb
- Diet Type:Grain-Free
- Special Ingredients:Prebiotics, Probiotics
Our verdict“Ideal for adult cats needing gentle, probiotic-enhanced nutrition without common grain fillers.”
Blue Buffalo Wilderness Chicken Grain-Free Dry Cat Food
Blue Buffalo Wilderness sets a high standard with real chicken as the first ingredient and its proprietary LifeSource Bits antioxidant blend. When compared to the I AND LOVE AND YOU Naked Essentials, Blue Buffalo offers a more comprehensive immune support system through added vitamins and minerals, making it a robust choice for overall wellness. The formula is strictly grain-free, avoiding common allergens like corn and wheat, which aligns with the ancestral diet of cats more closely than many competitors. However, it is specifically formulated for adult cats, so it lacks the nutrient profile needed for kittens or senior cats with specific renal needs. The 6 lb bag size offers a balance between freshness and convenience, though it may not suit households with multiple cats. It remains a top-tier option for owners seeking a balanced, high-protein diet with proven antioxidant benefits.
Pros:- Real chicken is the first ingredient
- Contains LifeSource Bits for immune health
- Rich in omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids
- Made in the USA without artificial preservatives
Cons:- Not suitable for kittens or all life stages
- Contains chicken, excluding cats with poultry sensitivities
Best for: Owners of adult cats seeking a balanced, high-protein diet with added immune support.
Not ideal for: Kittens, senior cats with kidney issues, or cats with poultry allergies.
- Brand:Blue Buffalo
- Primary Protein:Real Chicken
- Life Stage:Adult
- Bag Size:6 lb
- Diet Features:Grain-free, High-Protein
- Special Ingredients:LifeSource Bits, Omega Fatty Acids
- Origin:USA
Our verdict“A well-rounded, high-quality option for adult cats needing immune support and balanced nutrition.”
How We Picked
I evaluated these products based on ingredient transparency, nutritional completeness, and digestibility. First, I examined the ingredient lists to ensure the primary protein sources were named meats rather than vague by-products. I also checked for artificial preservatives, colors, or flavors, which are common irritants for sensitive pets. Second, I considered the formulation intent. Some foods are designed for weight management, while others focus on skin and coat health or limited ingredients for allergies. A product cannot be ranked highly if it fails to meet the nutritional standards for its intended life stage. Finally, I assessed value per calorie. While premium ingredients cost more, the serving size recommendations vary widely. A small bag of dense, nutrient-rich food may last longer than a large bag of filler-heavy kibble, making the effective cost comparable.
| grain free dog and cat food | Flavor | Form | Life stage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Loyal Saints Freeze-Dried Raw | Turkey and salmon | Freeze-dried | All life stages |
| The Honest Kitchen Grain-Free | Turkey | Pellet clusters | All life stages |
| Evanger’s Grain-Free Chicken W | Chicken | Chunks | All life stages |
| Natural Balance Limited Ingred | Salmon & Green Pea | Pellet | Adult |
| Nature’s Logic Grain-Free Beef | Beef | Dry | All life stages |
| Grandma Mae’s Country Naturals | — | — | Adult (Senior/Weight Control) |
| Jinx Grain-Free Dry Dog Food w | — | — | All Life Stages |
| I AND LOVE AND YOU Naked Essen | — | — | Adult |
| Blue Buffalo Wilderness Chicke | — | — | Adult |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Grain Free Dog And Cat Food
Selecting the right grain-free diet involves more than just removing wheat or corn. You must consider your pet’s species, activity level, and medical history. Here are the key factors to weigh before making a purchase.Species-Specific Nutritional Requirements
One of the most common mistakes owners make is assuming dog and cat food are interchangeable. Cats are obligate carnivores, meaning they require higher protein levels and specific amino acids like taurine that dogs can synthesize themselves. Feeding dog food to a cat can lead to severe heart and vision problems over time. Conversely, cat food is often too rich in protein and fat for many dogs, potentially causing pancreatitis. When shopping, verify that the label explicitly states the species it is formulated for. If you have both pets, look for products that clearly delineate feeding instructions for each animal or choose species-specific bags to avoid accidental cross-feeding.
Understanding Alternative Carbohydrate Sources
Just because a food is grain-free does not mean it is low-carb. Manufacturers often replace grains with legumes, potatoes, or peas to bind the kibble together. Some veterinary research has linked high levels of these ingredients to dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) in certain dog breeds. If your dog is predisposed to heart issues, look for formulas that use lower-carb alternatives or higher meat content. Cats generally tolerate these carbohydrates better than dogs, but obesity remains a risk. Check the guaranteed analysis for carbohydrate estimates and prioritize products where the first few ingredients are whole meats, not starchy fillers.
Form Factor: Dry Kibble vs. Wet vs. Freeze-Dried
The physical form of the food impacts hydration, dental health, and convenience. Dry kibble is convenient and helps scrape plaque from teeth, but it contains low moisture, which can be problematic for cats prone to urinary crystals. Wet food offers high moisture content, supporting kidney and urinary health, but it can be messy and expensive. Freeze-dried or raw options preserve the most nutrients and enzymes but require proper storage and often need rehydration. For senior pets or those with dental issues, softer textures like wet or rehydrated freeze-dried food are often easier to consume. Consider your daily routine and your pet’s health needs when choosing the format.
Limited Ingredient Diets for Allergy Management
If your pet suffers from chronic itching or digestive upset, a limited ingredient diet (LID) is often the best starting point. These foods contain fewer components, making it easier to identify the specific trigger if a reaction occurs. However, LID is not a cure-all; it is a diagnostic tool. Once the allergen is identified, you may need to switch to a novel protein diet rather than staying on the LID forever. When comparing LID options, look for a single, novel protein source (like venison, duck, or salmon) that your pet has not eaten before. Avoid LID products that contain multiple potential allergens like chicken and wheat simultaneously, as this defeats the purpose.
Cost Per Serving vs. Bag Price
Grain-free foods often carry a premium price tag, but the cost per serving is the true metric of value. Nutrient-dense foods, such as freeze-dried or high-protein kibble, require smaller portions because they are more efficiently utilized by the body. A cheaper bag of kibble might seem economical until you realize you are feeding double the amount to maintain your pet’s weight. Additionally, consider the waste factor. Palatable foods that pets eat willingly reduce waste, whereas finicky eaters may leave behind expensive leftovers. Calculate the monthly cost based on your pet’s recommended daily calorie intake rather than just comparing the sticker price of the bag.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is grain-free food actually better for all dogs and cats?
No, grain-free food is not inherently better for every pet. Many animals tolerate grains like rice or oats without any issues. Grain-free diets are primarily beneficial for pets with specific grain allergies or sensitivities, which are relatively rare compared to protein allergies. In fact, some grain-free formulas use legumes or potatoes, which can cause digestive upset in some animals. Unless a veterinarian has diagnosed a grain intolerance, a balanced diet with whole grains can be a healthy, cost-effective choice. Always consult with your vet before making significant dietary changes based on trends rather than medical need.
Can I feed the same grain-free food to both my dog and my cat?
You should not feed the same food to both species unless the product is explicitly labeled as a multi-species supplement, which is rare for main meals. Cats have higher protein requirements and need added taurine, an amino acid that is critical for their heart and eye health but not essential for dogs. Dog food lacks sufficient taurine for cats, leading to serious health issues if fed long-term. Additionally, cat food is often too high in calories and fat for dogs, potentially leading to obesity or pancreatitis. Always purchase species-specific formulas to ensure each animal receives the correct nutrient balance.
How do I transition my pet to a new grain-free diet?
A sudden switch to a new food can cause vomiting and diarrhea, even if the new food is high-quality. I recommend a gradual transition over 7 to 10 days. Start by mixing 25% new food with 75% old food for the first two days. Then, move to a 50/50 mix for days 3 and 4, followed by 75% new food for days 5 and 6. Finally, feed 100% new food on day 7. This slow change allows your pet’s gut microbiome to adjust to the new ingredient profile. If you notice any digestive upset, slow down the transition or consult your veterinarian.
Does grain-free food help with skin allergies and itching?
Grain-free food may help if your pet’s itching is caused by a grain allergy, but this is less common than protein allergies. Most food allergies in dogs and cats are triggered by proteins like chicken, beef, or dairy. If you switch to grain-free but keep the same protein source, you will likely see no improvement. For skin issues, a novel protein diet (using a protein the pet has never eaten) or a hydrolyzed protein diet is often more effective. Grain-free is a tool, not a guaranteed solution, so identifying the actual allergen through elimination diets is the most logical step.
Are there risks associated with grain-free diets regarding heart health?
The FDA has investigated a potential link between certain grain-free diets and Dilated Cardiomyopathy (DCM) in dogs, particularly those using peas, lentils, or potatoes as primary carbohydrate sources. This association is not proven to be causal, but it is significant enough that owners of predisposed breeds (like Golden Retrievers or Boxers) should be cautious. Look for foods that do not rely heavily on these legumes, or choose formulas that have been tested for cardiac safety. Cats are generally not affected by this specific issue. Discussing breed-specific risks with your veterinarian is the best way to mitigate potential concerns.
Conclusion
Selecting the best grain free dog and cat food depends on your pet’s individual health needs and your lifestyle. For the highest nutritional quality and minimal processing, Loyal Saints Freeze-Dried Raw Turkey and Salmon is the best overall choice, particularly for pets with severe sensitivities. If you prefer the convenience of dry food without sacrificing ingredient quality, The Honest Kitchen Grain-Free Turkey & Superfoods offers an excellent balance of whole-food ingredients and ease of use. For cat owners, Natural Balance Limited Ingredient Adult Dry Cat Food is the best value pick for managing allergies with a simple, salmon-based formula. Those with senior dogs or pets needing weight management should consider Grandma Mae’s Country Naturals for its lower-calorie profile. Finally, for a multi-pet household needing a versatile wet option, Evanger’s Grain-Free Chicken Wet Food provides essential hydration for both species. Always monitor your pet’s response to any new diet and consult your veterinarian for personalized advice.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
